unit 20 The Boundary Question
Glossary

The Boundary Question

The Boundary Commission was set up under the terms of the Anglo-Irish Treaty signed in London between the British Government and the representatives of the Sinn Féin leadership on 6th December 1921. According to section 12 of the document, the Commission’s function would be to "determine in accordance with the wishes of the inhabitants, so far as may be compatible with economic and geographic conditions, the boundaries between Northern Ireland and the rest of Ireland."

Unionists were bitterly hostile to this provision as they said the issue of the border had already been settled by the 1920 Government of Ireland Act that had set up Northern Ireland. In order to get the work of the Commission off the ground, the British Government ended up appointing a representative on their behalf, J.R. Fisher, a unionist intellectual and former editor of the Northern Whig. Nationalists, on the other hand, were much more positive. They were convinced that the criterion of the “wishes of the inhabitants” would lead to areas with a Catholic nationalist majority being transferred to Dublin. Thus, according to the Londonderry Sentinel (June 11, 1925), “Nationalists [claimed] the counties of Tyrone and Fermanagh, the city of Derry, and portions of the counties of Londonderry, Armagh and Down.” They hoped that the loss of such large areas would weaken Northern Ireland to such an extent that it would soon have no choice but to become part of the Free State or, perhaps, a future Republic.

The Commission finally began its work in 1924 under the chairmanship of Mr Justice Richard Feetham, a judge of the Supreme Court of the Union of South Africa. One of the biggest problems it faced was how it should interpret Article 12 of the Treaty. Could the Commission "re-draw" the border from scratch? Or should it limit itself to merely "adjusting" the existing boundary? In the end it was decided that the Commission did not have a mandate to introduce fundamental changes to the 1920 settlement and could only envisage marginal transfers of land on either side of the existing border. 

The Commission divided its time between London and travelling on the ground in areas on both sides of the existing border. It took evidence in the form of written and oral statements from public bodies such as urban and rural district councils, professional associations, and political registration associations, as well as from private individuals such as those with commercial or business interests. Before it was ready to publish its report, its main findings, recommending limited transfers of territory in both directions, were leaked to a British newspaper, the conservative Morning Post, which published a proposed map of the changes on 7th November 1925. The resulting scandal led to the resignation of the Free State representative, Eoin MacNeill, and the stalling of the entire process. 

In order to break the deadlock, tripartite negotiations then began between London, Dublin and Belfast and the result, announced on 3rd December 1925, was that the existing border was to be confirmed exactly as it stood, the Free State being released from the payment of certain financial obligations by way of compensation.

IMAGE: This map appeared in the Northern Whig and Belfast Post, on the 9th November, 1925. It is a copy of the original map of the Boundary Settlement, as leaked by the Morning Post, on 7th November, 1925.